You are here
- Home
- Publications
- RUSI Journal
- Volume: 162
- No: 1
- Designing Conceptual Failure in Warfare: The Misguided Path of the West

Designing Conceptual Failure in Warfare: The Misguided Path of the West
Peter RobertsRUSI Journal, 3 April 2017
Military Sciences, Profession of Arms, Defence Policy, Global Security Issues, Technology
In this examination of modern warfare doctrine and strategies, Peter Roberts argues that Western militaries are constrained by thirteenth-century theological philosophy and Napoleonic dogma, while their enemies have leapt ahead into the twenty-first century – not simply in technological terms, but in the very way they have reimagined warfare.
Continue Reading
Become A Member
To access the full text of this article and many other benefits, become a RUSI member.
Author
Director Military Sciences, RUSI
Peter is Director of Military Sciences at the Royal United Services Institute, having been the Senior Research Fellow for Sea Power and... read more
Support Rusi Research
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Related

FCAS: Is the Franco-German-Spanish Combat Air Programme Really in Trouble?
Commentary, 1 March 2021Justin Bronk
A new European combat aircraft is still likely to emerge from a programme plagued by mismatched national positions, priorities and industrial responsibilities.
Tags: Aerospace, Military Sciences, Germany, France, Europe
21st-Century Assistance Dogs? Harnessing Data and Technology
Conference Reports, 1 March 2021Paul O’Neill and Alison Gregory
This report reflects the learning from a RUSI/PA Consulting-hosted series of discussion groups on data and technology. The groups were held between June and December 2020, and featured representatives from the public sector, multiple industry sectors and academics.
Tags: Military Sciences, Conference Reports, Technology
Reports of the ‘Failure’ of the F-35 are Premature and Exaggerated
RUSI Defence Systems, 25 February 2021Justin Bronk
The announcement that a forthcoming US Air Force TacAir study will include an assessment of a new clean sheet design to replace the F-16 has led many to label the F-35 a failure. While it is certainly an important change in public messaging, the underlying dynamics do not support this interpretation.
Tags: Air Power and Technology, Martial Power Programme, Military Sciences, RUSI Defence SystemsPages

FCAS: Is the Franco-German-Spanish Combat Air Programme Really in Trouble?
Commentary, 1 March 2021Justin Bronk
A new European combat aircraft is still likely to emerge from a programme plagued by mismatched national positions, priorities and industrial responsibilities.
Tags: Aerospace, Military Sciences, Germany, France, Europe
Failure to Lift Off: The UK’s Space Launch Ambitions
Commentary, 24 February 2021Alexandra Stickings
Creating an indigenous space launch capability is considered by many to be a key aspect of the UK’s space ambitions. Yet there are questions as to whether current plans recognise the challenges ahead.
Tags: Aerospace, Military Sciences, UK Integrated Review 2021, UK
5G and Emerging Technology: The Politics of Diversification
Commentary, 15 February 2021James Sullivan
The UK government must learn quickly from its policy decisions around its 5G networks, and start grappling much earlier with risks posed by other emerging technologies.
Tags: Cyber Security, UK Integrated Review 2021, UK, TechnologyPages

Reports of the ‘Failure’ of the F-35 are Premature and Exaggerated
RUSI Defence Systems, 25 February 2021Justin Bronk
The announcement that a forthcoming US Air Force TacAir study will include an assessment of a new clean sheet design to replace the F-16 has led many to label the F-35 a failure. While it is certainly an important change in public messaging, the underlying dynamics do not support this interpretation.
Tags: Air Power and Technology, Martial Power Programme, Military Sciences, RUSI Defence Systems
Russian Electronic Warfare, Cyber and Information Operations in Ukraine: Implications for NATO and Security in the Baltic States
RUSI Journal, 24 February 2021Duncan McCrory
Russia's investment in its electronic, cyber and information capabilities should concern NATO states.
Tags: Cyber, RUSI Journal, Russia, Information, Technology
Between a Pandemic and a Hard Brexit: Grand Strategic Thinking in an Age of Nationalism, Renewed Geopolitical Competition and Human Insecurity
RUSI Journal, 24 February 2021William D James
The UK's turbulent domestic situation has implications for how the country faces external threats.
Tags: RUSI Journal, UK, Defence Policy, UK DefencePages

The Origins of Economic Sanctions
Multimedia, 28 May 2020Dr Nicholas Mulder talks to RUSI's Dr Jonathan Eyal about the origins of economic sanctions and their relevance today. Nicholas Mulder is an associate professor at Cornell University and is author of...
Global Security Issues
Russian and Chinese Air Defences
Multimedia, 1 May 2020Justin Bronk, Research Fellow at RUSI outlines the current state of Russian and Chinese air defence capabilities.
Adversarial Studies, Aerospace, Military Sciences, Profession of Arms, Russia, UK, Technology
The Challenge of Change: Acquiring Technologies for Defence in the UK
Multimedia, 7 April 2020Peggy Hollinger, International Business Editor at the Financial Times discusses a new RUSI paper authored by Trevor Taylor and John Louth. The paper suggests that the UK needs a speedier defence...
Armed Forces, Defence, Industries and Society, Defence Spending, Equipment and Acquisitions, UK, Defence Policy, UK Defence, EuropePages

New Partnership with the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism
News, 8 June 2018New international research network to examine terrorists' use of internet technologies.
Cyber, Future UK Cyber Security Strategy Project, Terrorism and Conflict, The Global Research Network on Terrorism and Technology, National Security, Technology, Terrorism
RUSI at the Munich Security Conference
News, 23 February 2018Last week RUSI Director-General, Dr Karin von Hippel, and Deputy Director-General, Professor Malcolm Chalmers, attended the Munich Security Conference.
Global Security Issues
Robert Hannigan, former director of GCHQ, becomes RUSI Senior Associate Fellow
News, 4 January 2018RUSI is delighted to announce the appointment of Robert Hannigan CMG as Senior Associate Fellow.
Cyber, Intelligence, TechnologyPages

Bridging the Innovation Gap: How to Improve Cooperation Between Tech Startups and the National Security Community
Events, 22 September 2020At this event chaired by Sir Michael Fallon, NATO Assistant Secretary-General Giedrimas Jeglinskas, Isar Aerospace Co-Founder and CEO Daniel Metzler and Dr Staffan Truvé, Co-Founder and CTO, Recorded...
Tags: Military Sciences, Modern Deterrence
Keeping Online Payments Safe: Resilience of Digital Payments
Events, 2 September 2020Online payments are accelerating, not least as a result of coronavirus-related lifestyle changes.
Tags: Military Sciences, Modern Deterrence
Paper Launch: Performing Information Manoeuvre Through Persistent Engagement
Events, 11 June 2020At this launch event Nick Reynolds will explore RUSI's independent study examining the information operating environment.
Tags: Military Sciences
New Zealand's Indo-Pacific Recalibration
The Budding Alliance Between Lockdown Critics and the Far-Right in Germany
FCAS: Is the Franco-German-Spanish Combat Air Programme Really in Trouble?